Microvariation in the Have Yet To Construction
Matthew Tyler, Jim Wood
March 2018
 

The have yet to construction, exemplified by sentences such as John has yet to visit his grandmother, is widespread across dialects of English. However, recent studies have revealed that behind this apparent unity, there is significant variation in the syntactic properties of the have yet to construction. Speakers vary with respect to (i) the status of have as an auxiliary or main verb, (ii) the status of negation tests, and (iii) the status of a variety of related yet to constructions. The goal of this paper is to sort out the microsyntax of have yet to across speakers, in the face of contradictory empirical claims and mutually incompatible proposals in the existing literature. We develop an analysis based in part on several wide-scale surveys we have conducted. With respect to have, we show that speakers who can treat it as a main verb can also treat it as an auxiliary, but not necessarily vice-versa. We propose that the variation in this case has to do with where the PERFect features are introduced in the clause. With respect to negation, we find that speakers do not treat all the negation tests the same, forcing us to contend with the question of how these tests work. We propose that for most speakers, only the embedded clause is syntactically negative. Negation tests split according to whether they must target the matrix clause, or whether they can target an embedded clause as well. In some cases, the tests reveal the same sentence to be both affirmative and negative, as we expect: the matrix clause is syntactically affirmative, but the embedded clause, which hosts the lexical content, is syntactically negative.
Format: [ pdf ]
Reference: lingbuzz/003950
(please use that when you cite this article)
Published in: Linguistic Variation 19 (2), 232–279.
keywords: have yet to, got yet to, have yet for, have still to, be yet to, yet, negation, negation tests, npis, silent verbs, do-support, perfect aspect, auxiliaries, microvariation, dialect syntax, english dialects, acceptability judgments, reverse agree, so-inversion, neither-inversion, not even, slifting, syntax
Downloaded:343 times

 

[ edit this article | back to article list ]